Paradise turns dangerous, but cover up is worse: ‘It is ridiculous to claim Dubai is safe’

Life in the once relatively free tourist attraction of Dubai has reportedly turned hellish amid the ongoing war in Iran, especially for expats.

Radha Stirling, a human rights activist and founder of Detained in Dubai, knows all about it.

“In recent days, we at Detained in Dubai have been inundated with cases of expats who have been detained after sharing images of drone strikes and explosions, even when those images were merely sent privately to family members simply to reassure them that they were safe,” Stirling wrote for a Daily Mail report published Tuesday.

“In several cases we have handled, authorities attended buildings in the aftermath, requesting access to residents’ phones and reviewing personal content on the spot. Those found to have taken photographs, even if never shared publicly, were arrested,” she added.

The problem, it appears, is that the United Arab Emirates (UAE) wants the public to believe the war in Iran won’t affect them. But that’s not the reality on the ground, according to Stirling.

“It is ridiculous to claim Dubai is safe,” she explained. “People have been killed and injured, and residents are receiving ‘take cover’ alerts, sending them to shelter in car parks with their families. We are receiving calls all day from people trapped by travel bans over trivial matters like landlord disputes, desperately trying to get out to safety.”

ADVERTISEMENT

The crazy thing about all this, she continued, is that none of this is new — that, despite all the pro-Dubai propaganda that’s always been pushed, the city has never been a beacon of freedom.

She explained that the reality in Dubai is that “a negative review can land you in prison” and that “victims of crime are often silenced through pressure, pay-offs or threats.”

Hell, just criticism — mere criticism — of the government in the UAE is illegal:

Why then do so many people believe otherwise? Because of all the propaganda pumped out directly by the UAE government and the influencers it hires to do its dirty work.

ADVERTISEMENT

“Scroll through social media and you will see it everywhere: infinity pools, supercars, ‘safe streets’, and the promise of a better life,” Stirling wrote.

“Celebrities and high-profile entrepreneurs reinforce the narrative, and many expats feel pressure to promote Dubai in a positive light. What you won’t see are the legal realities that sit beneath that polished surface, the arbitrary detentions, human rights violations and even deaths in custody,” she added.

Undergirding this “strict system of censorship” is what Stirling described as “sweeping cybercrime laws that govern not only what people say publicly, but what they share privately.”

She explained that under these laws, actions that would seem trivial in the West can wind up being a very big deal.

ADVERTISEMENT

Such actions include “sending a message that contains profanity,” “sharing a post authorities later deem false, disagreeable or misleading, ” “posting a negative review about a company,” and “even complaining about poor customer service.”

“There have been cases of individuals detained over private WhatsApp messages exchanged between friends, spouses, flatmates or colleagues,” Stirling pointed out.

“Others have faced legal action for social media posts made years earlier, outside the UAE, only to be arrested upon arrival as happened to British national Laleh Shahravesh, detained in Dubai over Facebook comments written in the UK years earlier,” she continued explaining.

Stirling concluded her report by warning expats who just arrived in Dubai or who have been there awhile but don’t intend to leave to be very, very careful.

“The UAE is one of the most digitally surveilled countries in the world, where VPNs are illegal and even private messages can be scrutinised,” she wrote.

ADVERTISEMENT
Vivek Saxena

Comment

We have no tolerance for comments containing violence, racism, profanity, vulgarity, doxing, or discourteous behavior. If a comment is spam, instead of replying to it please click the ∨ icon below and to the right of that comment. Thank you for partnering with us to maintain fruitful conversation.

Latest Articles