‘Freedom of expression is not absolute’: Judge slaps Brazilian comedian with 8 years in prison for offensive jokes

A Brazilian comedian has been sentenced to eight whopping years in prison for simply telling allegedly “bigoted” jokes.

Comedian Leo Lins was hit with the sentence on Tuesday for allegedly making discriminatory jokes about black people, fat people, old people, AIDs victims, homosexuals, evangelicals, indigenous people, etc.

The guy was and is basically an equal opportunity offender who targets EVERYBODY.

Despite his jokes being just that — JOKES! — a federal court in São Paulo ruled that his right to free speech isn’t absolute, especially when said speech comes up against other people’s human dignity.

“Freedom of expression is not absolute nor unlimited,” Judge Barbara de Lima Iseppi ruled, according to The Washington Post.

“When there is a confrontation between the fundamental precept of liberty of expression and the principles of human dignity and judicial equality, the latter should win out,” the ruling continued.

ADVERTISEMENT

According to Euro Weekly News, the court was specifically concerned about jokes Lins made during a 2022 show called “Perturbador,” or “Disturbing.”

“The public prosecutor’s office filed a complaint about the content, and in 2023, a different court ordered the video to be removed from the internet,” according to EWN. “By that time, it had already amassed over three million views.”

Ironically, in “Perturbador,” Lins fiercely defended the “inclusivity” of his comedy.

“I make jokes about everything and everyone,” he said. “What show could be more inclusive? I even hired a sign language interpreter just to be able to offend the deaf-mute.”

Watch the full special below (a bootleg copy was reportedly uploaded to YouTube by one of Lins’ fans):

ADVERTISEMENT

In addition to being sentenced to time in prison, Lins has also been hit with a 300,000 reais ($63,953.92) fine.

“Watching a comedian receive the same punishment as someone convicted of drug trafficking, corruption, or even murder, all because of jokes told on stage, is deeply troubling,” his lawyer reportedly said after the controversial ruling.

A number of other comedians have since come to Lins’ defense.

“You might not find Leo Lins’s jokes funny — you might even detest them — but sentencing someone to prison over them is madness and harmful,” comedian Antonio Tabet reportedly tweeted in Portuguese. “I hope this irrational decision is overturned.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Comedian Jonathan Nemmer meanwhile lamented that Brazil has turned into “a country that takes comedians’ jokes seriously but treats politicians’ actions as a joke.”

Sadly, this ruling is nothing new in Brazil, a country that’s increasingly turned toward the authoritarian, free-speech-suppressing left by not only censoring comedy but also so-called “misinformation” as well.

“In recent years, the country’s Supreme Court has repeatedly moved to block and remove the online accounts of people it alleged were spreading misinformation that could endanger Brazilian democracy,” the Post notes.

“The country has also assumed an increasingly hard-line position against racist speech, which is considered a crime in Brazil,” the report continues.

Last year, for example, influencer Day McCarthy was also sentenced to eight years in prison. Why? Because she’d allegedly made racist remarks about the adopted black child of a white celebrity couple.

ADVERTISEMENT

In the eyes of Brazilian prosecutors like Lívia Vaz, talking such nonsense is a crime.

“This crime has historically been met with minimal consequences, like community service,” she told the Latin Times. “Now, we’re seeing more arrests and prison sentences.”

Yay?

Critics, for their part, don’t like any of this censorship.

Look:

Vivek Saxena

Comment

We have no tolerance for comments containing violence, racism, profanity, vulgarity, doxing, or discourteous behavior. If a comment is spam, instead of replying to it please click the ∨ icon below and to the right of that comment. Thank you for partnering with us to maintain fruitful conversation.

Latest Articles