Leftists, particularly black ones, are furious that conservatives are trying to stop a racially discriminatory program from moving forward.
Instituted by San Francisco, the Abundant Birth Project is designed to give “$1,000 per month to nearly 150 [b]lack residents during a portion of their pregnancies and the first six months of their children’s live,” according to local station KQED.
As evident by the program’s description, it only applies to black mothers, therefore making it a racially discriminatory and patently racist program that takes taxpayer money and hands it out to only black people. It’s for this reason that San Francisco has been justifiably sued by civil rights activists.
“The American Civil Rights Project, along with Benbrook Law Group, filed a complaint May 31 in San Francisco County Superior Court on behalf of named plaintiffs Ruth Parker, Ellen Lee Zhou and the Californians for Equal Rights Foundation,” according to the Northern California Record.
Lawsuit: San Francisco’s race, identity-based ‘guaranteed income’ projects violate the Constitution https://t.co/eRGHgiZTqA
— NorCal Record (@NorCal_Record) June 13, 2023
The class action suit targets the city and of county of San Francisco, in addition to the San Francisco Unified School District, Regents of the University of California, and California Health and Human Services Agency Secretary Mark Ghaly over several discriminatory income programs, including the Abundant Birth Project.
The lawsuit reportedly states that the agencies participating in the programs are violating the 14th Amendment because they “unlawfully choose their beneficiaries based on race, ethnicity, gender/gender identity and sexual orientation.”
“[The] payment schemes also discriminate unlawfully on the bases of gender/gender identity and sexual orientation. Although courts have held that the federal constitution’s equal protection guarantee is more tolerant of such classifications than it is with racial distinctions, the California Constitution treats sex and sexual orientation as ‘suspect classifications,’” the lawsuit continues.
According to the Northern California Record, the suit specifically targets the Abundant Birth Project, the Black Economic Equity Movement, and the Guaranteed Income for Transgender People program.
“Whether explicitly creating programs targeted toward racial or identity groups, or using intentional proxies, ‘no compelling interest supports these discriminatory giveaways,’ the complaint allege[s]. ‘Indeed, defendants do not even attempt to identify an interest recognized by the United States Supreme Court as compelling,'” the paper notes.
While these all appear to be fair arguments, the reaction from leftists — particularly to the suit’s focus on the Abundant Birth Project — has been one of fury, with them accusing Republicans of being the racist ones for not approving a racist program.
Look:
I’m so tired of these people and their hate
— Hoochie Daddy Shorts Confirmation Specialist (@Shes_deathProof) November 24, 2023
If white people can’t have something they will take it, steal it or destroy it.
— Petty Pablo (@electricsoul123) November 24, 2023
They seem only interested in coming after projects that benefit Black people. I wonder why???
— Carla W. ️ (@CarlaJWms) November 24, 2023
These groups led by conservatives and libertarians don’t want Black ppl to have access to the money we’ve paid into the system ever!
— Harem Rebels (@Angelic1_Decree) November 24, 2023
This is so shameful. They can’t have a situation where Black people are assisted. They want a foot on Black folks necks at all times. This is insane.
— Tonya Kent (@tonya_ck) November 24, 2023
Republicans don’t want to help anyone who needs help but they especially do not want to help people of color.
Don’t take away this stipend. Expand the program.
— Make it Stop – Liberty and Justice for All (@mcarr2021) November 26, 2023
“Black women have the highest maternal mortality rate in the U.S. – 69.9 per 100,000 live births for 2021, almost three times the rate for white women…”
So OF COURSE conservatives attack the very project addressing these racial disparities by claiming it’s discriminatory.— Organized curiosity ️️⚧️ (@fundthescience) November 25, 2023
FYI, it’s not a “claim” that the program is discriminatory — it’s a fact.
Moreover, plenty of Americans realize this. Indeed, for every X user complaining about the suit, there was an X user rightly pointing out that the suit is 100 percent justified.
Look:
Laws that specifically benefit or condemn people based on protected characteristics are bad right?
— citizenpew (@citizenpew) November 25, 2023
Well if they only gave the stipend to a group devoid of color, I know for absolute certainty that some groups of color would be suing.
— WMS (@lolpersonified) November 25, 2023
This is beyond justified. Giving out gas money to anyone, regardless of race is ridiculous. Not only that, you don’t need any hand out from anyone. Period. Why?
— Jamie Girl (@Jamie29036) November 26, 2023
And that’s because it does discriminate based on race. And that’s unconstitutional in this country. It should be shut down, or better yet, it should be modified to make it a lawful project not conditioned upon race.
— happy lil terf (@terfforever) November 25, 2023
It is a race base program, which sets benefits based on race. Why not just take the race part out?
Do half black women get less? Do 25% Asian get nothing?
What is up with you people?
— Michigan-Canadian Front (@MichiganFront) November 24, 2023
What’s up with these folks is they’ve been brainwashed to think racial discrimination and bigotry is alright if it helps black people. However, racial discrimination and bigotry is in fact NEVER acceptable.
- Veterans slam Democrat candidate for misrepresenting Naval rank and aren’t buying his excuses - March 27, 2026
- ‘I can’t breathe!’ Transgender atty tackled and arrested for disobeying judge shuts down law firm - March 27, 2026
- Former CIA officer recommends anti-Trump protesters use Serbian tactics - March 27, 2026
Comment
We have no tolerance for comments containing violence, racism, profanity, vulgarity, doxing, or discourteous behavior. If a comment is spam, instead of replying to it please click the ∨ icon below and to the right of that comment. Thank you for partnering with us to maintain fruitful conversation.
