San Francisco reassesses public monuments in sweeping review

Monuments and memorials across San Francisco are getting fresh scrutiny as critics and city officials question their relevance and history.

A continuing look at “heroic” figures memorialized in statues and sculptures is prompting the San Francisco Arts Commission to work with the city in reassessing public works, with officials saying “the aim is to encourage engagement and critical thinking about public art, rather than passive acceptance,” according to ABC News.

“The Arts Commission has spent the past several years auditing the city’s public art collection and determining which stories should be highlighted,” ABC News reported, noting that “monuments have raised questions about their relevance” across the California city.

The report cited examples of “controversial” statues being removed, like the Christopher Columbus monument that was removed in June 2020 by the Arts Commission ” early in the morning, away from public view.”

“The city said the monument did not align with San Francisco’s values or its commitment to racial justice,” the outlet reported, adding that another work titled “Early Days,” was removed in 2018 “after critics said it depicted and glorified the oppression of Native Americans. Installed in 1894, the statue left behind an empty space that remains unfilled.”

The report cited several more examples of monuments that were erected in San Francisco over the decades that “had nothing to do with” the city, including a statue donated by Mexico in 1962 of Miguel Hidalgo y Costilla, a leader of the Mexican War of Independence.

ADVERTISEMENT

“The city is now considering whether it should continue accepting such gifted monuments,” ABC News noted.

“The era of the permanent bronze statue of a single heroic figure is over,” the Arts Commission declared.

“We don’t want to eliminate, we don’t want to revise, we want to explain,” Commissioner Charles Collins said. “To ensure that the art that is put there, that is placed there, that we are privileged to bring them, also has a very strong community voice.”

The latest liberal attempts to revise history to be more acceptable triggered a wave of reactions on social media.

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT
Frieda Powers

Comment

We have no tolerance for comments containing violence, racism, profanity, vulgarity, doxing, or discourteous behavior. If a comment is spam, instead of replying to it please click the ∨ icon below and to the right of that comment. Thank you for partnering with us to maintain fruitful conversation.

Latest Articles